Venture

A close look at Singapore’s thriving startup ecosystem

Comment

futuristic RENDITION of Singapore
Image Credits: Getty Images under a lupengyu (opens in a new window) license.

Toni Eliasz

Contributor

Toni Eliasz is the program manager of the Disruptive Technologies for Development Program (DT4D) that supports the innovation and adoption of technology-driven solutions in World Bank Group operations. In addition, Toni works on several digital-economy-related initiatives that support the scaling of digital businesses, stimulate startup ecosystems and accelerate the digital transformation of key industries in Africa, Asia, the Caribbean and the Middle East.

Singapore is home to fewer than six million people, making it one of the smallest ASEAN countries, in terms of population. It is a young country as well — having gained independence in 1963 — and resides in a neighborhood with far larger economies, including China, Indonesia, and Vietnam. When the country first became independent, its mandate was to simply survive rather than thrive.

So how does a country evolve from a position of relative uncertainty, with comparatively few resources, to one that leads the ASEAN region in venture capital investment and has been home to 10 unicorns?

Countries around the world examine Singapore’s ecosystem from a distance, hoping to learn from, and emulate, its story. The World Bank Group recently published a report, The Evolution and State of Singapore’s Start-up Ecosystem, documenting the country’s experience in building its startup ecosystem and the challenges facing it.

This article presents an overview of the report’s key findings and offers a few key recommendations on what other countries can learn from Singapore’s experience, as well as what Singapore itself can do to maintain progress.

A glimpse into Singapore’s current startup ecosystem

As of 2019, Singapore had over $19 billion in PE and VC assets under management, more than twice that of neighboring Indonesia, Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Thailand combined. In that same year, the country was home to an estimated 3,600 tech startups and nearly 200 different intermediary and supporting organizations (accelerators, co-working spaces, coding academies, etc.) – some which have a multinational presence, such as Blk71, whose Singapore headquarters has been referred to as “the world’s most tightly packed entrepreneurial ecosystem.”

While assessing the size and strength of startup ecosystems is an evolving method, Start-up Genome priced Singapore’s ecosystem at over $25 billion, five times the global median.

Arguably, the most eye-catching hallmark of this ecosystem is its population of current and former unicorns. Collectively, Singapore has been home to ten unicorns, three of which have offered an IPO (Nanofilm, Razer and Sea) and two of which have been acquired – one by giant Alibaba (Lazada) and one by Chinese streaming powerhouse YY (Bigo Live). The remaining five are Trax, Acronis, JustCo, PatSnap, and Grab – the ASEAN region’s largest unicorn to date.

 

The education sector is also prominent in Singapore’s ecosystem. Universities like the National University of Singapore (NUS) and Nanyang Technological University (NTU) are deeply embedded into this ecosystem, helping with R&D commercialization linkages, incubation, talent/knowledge transfer, and other areas.

So, how did Singapore’s startup ecosystem come to be?

Numerous factors have contributed to building Singapore’s startup ecosystem, with government intervention and leadership being the dominant driving forces. The government has spent more than USD60 billion over the past several decades to enhance the country’s R&D infrastructure, create VC funds, and launch accelerators and other support organizations.

Long before the country had any VC funds, accelerators, or unicorns — before the word “unicorn” was ever used to discuss startup growth or the country had even a basic semblance of a startup ecosystem — Singapore’s government began laying the foundation for an increasingly competitive, global economy and has spent decades embedding the country into global value chains. In 1989, after suffering its first recession, the government began focusing on R&D and specializing in high-technology to help Singapore catch-up with more advanced economies over the next 20 years.

The late 1990s saw the introduction of targeted strategies and policies focusing on entrepreneurs and startups themselves. These actions helped spur the country’s evolution from one focusing on building a business-friendly environment that is globally integrated into one concentrating heavily on supporting innovation and startups directly.

Singapore startup ecosystem timeline
Image Credits: Jamil Wyne and Toni Eliasz

In addition to direct government support to Singapore’s startup ecosystem, there have been other attributes that have helped shape it (many of which have also been government-driven). And while it is hard to separate the role of the government from Singapore’s startup ecosystem, the government has indicated that it understands the limitations of ecosystem development driven largely by the public sector and has increased its efforts to entice the private sector into taking a more active role in developing this ecosystem by encouraging the establishment of corporate venture funds and corporate startup programs.

Furthermore, the government has taken steps to utilize universities in their pursuit to build linkages between researchers, students, startups, and industry, as well as stimulate entrepreneurship.

What should the ecosystem focus on moving forward?

While Singapore has a number of impressive milestones in terms of its startup, VC, and accelerator communities, it must nonetheless address a series of lingering challenges. Our report suggests that, in addition to addressing an over-reliance on government, there are several priority areas to focus on in order to advance Singapore’s startup ecosystem, including:

  • Access to data – As part of our research we obtained data on various macro-level trends (e.g. overall VC flows in Singapore and the estimated size of the country’s startup population). However, many opaque areas remain. Although the government has spent tens of billions of dollars building-out its startup ecosystem, it is still unclear what this spending has legitimately yielded. Understanding the ecosystem’s contribution to the country’s labor market, GDP, gender equity, and other dimensions is critical.
  • Funding gaps – To date, while the supply of early-stage funding remains relatively consistent and sufficient, larger ticket sizes and the capitalization of niche sectors are relatively less common. While indeed, Singapore is putting a growing amount of capital and resources to work in the deep-tech space, these types of interventions typically require longer timelines for validating concepts and exiting them, and in parallel other sectors remain undercapitalized.
  • Retaining talent – Just as financial capital needs to move easily throughout an ecosystem, so, too, does human capital in functional markets. Arguably, entrepreneurs and employees are the lifeblood of a startup ecosystem. A relative dearth of local and foreign talent available to Singapore hinders this dimension.Singapore struggles with keeping its cost of living low enough to retain talent over the long-term, which affects employees across sectors. Processes enabling foreign talent to move to the country can also be difficult to navigate for young startups – an issue compounded by the fact that larger corporations can offer higher paying jobs, resulting in talent leaving the ecosystem.
  • Regional competition – Singapore leads all ASEAN countries in terms of overall VC funding and generally leads this regional startup pack by a wide margin. But while the gap in investment, the existence of unicorns, government spending, and overall startup activity between Singapore and its neighbors is significant, countries like Indonesia and Vietnam are continuing to build-out their ecosystems and divert talent and capital away from Singapore. In order to remain a regional hub, Singapore must ensure it stays relevant vis-a-vis its nearby ecosystems.

So what happens next?

Singapore’s startup ecosystem, much like the country itself, often captures the attention of countries around the world seeking to spur technology and startup-led growth. Rightfully so. There is a growing number of countries worldwide who aspire to create thriving, dynamic startup ecosystems – all of whom would be wise to contemplate lessons offered by Singapore’s experience.

Government leadership, the building of a business-friendly environment, and the development of talent (as well as specializing in industries that capitalize on this talent) are all trademarks that Singapore can showcase to other countries. However, Singapore’s development was not without growing pains either. For starters, while governments are needed to help jump-start ecosystems, they cannot always be the dominant player. Similarly, data gaps obscuring the true impact of an ecosystem can impede progress. In addition, even though Singapore has a relatively robust funding community, the country must still address gaps at later stages.

Finally, no ecosystem is an island and must collaborate with hubs in other countries. Singapore has strong economic ties throughout ASEAN, which has aided in solidifying its regional positioning. Yet those same countries are also competitors for talent and funding. Navigating such relationships is crucial for any country seeking to become a more relevant player in global startup and VC activity.

More TechCrunch

A data protection taskforce that’s spent over a year considering how the European Union’s data protection rulebook applies to OpenAI’s viral chatbot, ChatGPT, reported preliminary conclusions Friday. The top-line takeaway…

EU’s ChatGPT taskforce offers first look at detangling the AI chatbot’s privacy compliance

Here’s a shoutout to LatAm early-stage startup founders! We want YOU to apply for the Startup Battlefield 200 at TechCrunch Disrupt 2024. But you’d better hurry — time is running…

LatAm startups: Apply to Startup Battlefield 200

The countdown to early-bird savings for TechCrunch Disrupt, taking place October 28–30 in San Francisco, continues. You have just five days left to save up to $800 on the price…

5 days left to get your early-bird Disrupt passes

Venture investment into Spanish startups also held up quite well, with €2.2 billion raised across some 850 funding rounds.

Spanish startups reached €100 billion in aggregate value last year

Featured Article

Onyx Motorbikes was in trouble — and then its 37-year-old owner died

James Khatiblou, the owner and CEO of Onyx Motorbikes, was watching his e-bike startup fall apart.  Onyx was being evicted from its warehouse in El Segundo, Los Angeles. The company’s unpaid bills were stacking up. His chief operating officer had abruptly resigned. A shipment of around 100 CTY2 dirt bikes from Chinese supplier Suzhou Jindao…

13 hours ago
Onyx Motorbikes was in trouble — and then its 37-year-old owner died

Featured Article

Iyo thinks its gen AI earbuds can succeed where Humane and Rabbit stumbled

Iyo represents a third form factor in the push to deliver standalone generative AI devices: Bluetooth earbuds.

14 hours ago
Iyo thinks its gen AI earbuds can succeed where Humane and Rabbit stumbled

Arati Prabhakar, profiled as part of TechCrunch’s Women in AI series, is director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy.

Women in AI: Arati Prabhakar thinks it’s crucial to get AI ‘right’

AniML, the French startup behind a new 3D capture app called Doly, wants to create the PhotoRoom of product videos, sort of. If you’re selling sneakers on an online marketplace…

Doly lets you generate 3D product videos from your iPhone

Elon Musk’s AI startup, xAI, has raised $6 billion in a new funding round, it said today, as Musk shores up capital to aggressively compete with rivals including OpenAI, Microsoft,…

Elon Musk’s xAI raises $6B from Valor, a16z, and Sequoia

Indian startup Zypp Electric plans to use fresh investment from Japanese oil and energy conglomerate ENEOS to take its EV rental service into Southeast Asia early next year, TechCrunch has…

Indian EV startup Zypp Electric secures backing to fund expansion to Southeast Asia

Last month, one of the Bay Area’s better-known early-stage venture capital firms, Uncork Capital, marked its 20th anniversary with a party in a renovated church in San Francisco’s SoMa neighborhood,…

A venture capital firm looks back on changing norms, from board seats to backing rival startups

The families of victims of the shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas are suing Activision and Meta, as well as gun manufacturer Daniel Defense. The families bringing the…

Families of Uvalde shooting victims sue Activision and Meta

Like most Silicon Valley VCs, what Garry Tan sees is opportunities for new, huge, lucrative businesses.

Y Combinator’s Garry Tan supports some AI regulation but warns against AI monopolies

Everything in society can feel geared toward optimization – whether that’s standardized testing or artificial intelligence algorithms. We’re taught to know what outcome you want to achieve, and find the…

How Maven’s AI-run ‘serendipity network’ can make social media interesting again

Miriam Vogel, profiled as part of TechCrunch’s Women in AI series, is the CEO of the nonprofit responsible AI advocacy organization EqualAI.

Women in AI: Miriam Vogel stresses the need for responsible AI

Google has been taking heat for some of the inaccurate, funny, and downright weird answers that it’s been providing via AI Overviews in search. AI Overviews are the AI-generated search…

What are Google’s AI Overviews good for?

When it comes to the world of venture-backed startups, some issues are universal, and some are very dependent on where the startups and its backers are located. It’s something we…

The ups and downs of investing in Europe, with VCs Saul Klein and Raluca Ragab

Welcome back to TechCrunch’s Week in Review — TechCrunch’s newsletter recapping the week’s biggest news. Want it in your inbox every Saturday? Sign up here. OpenAI announced this week that…

Scarlett Johansson brought receipts to the OpenAI controversy

Accurate weather forecasts are critical to industries like agriculture, and they’re also important to help prevent and mitigate harm from inclement weather events or natural disasters. But getting forecasts right…

Deal Dive: Can blockchain make weather forecasts better? WeatherXM thinks so

pcTattletale’s website was briefly defaced and contained links containing files from the spyware maker’s servers, before going offline.

Spyware app pcTattletale was hacked and its website defaced

Featured Article

Synapse, backed by a16z, has collapsed, and 10 million consumers could be hurt

Synapse’s bankruptcy shows just how treacherous things are for the often-interdependent fintech world when one key player hits trouble. 

3 days ago
Synapse, backed by a16z, has collapsed, and 10 million consumers could be hurt

Sarah Myers West, profiled as part of TechCrunch’s Women in AI series, is managing director at the AI Now institute.

Women in AI: Sarah Myers West says we should ask, ‘Why build AI at all?’

Keeping up with an industry as fast-moving as AI is a tall order. So until an AI can do it for you, here’s a handy roundup of recent stories in the world…

This Week in AI: OpenAI and publishers are partners of convenience

Evan, a high school sophomore from Houston, was stuck on a calculus problem. He pulled up Answer AI on his iPhone, snapped a photo of the problem from his Advanced…

AI tutors are quietly changing how kids in the US study, and the leading apps are from China

Welcome to Startups Weekly — Haje‘s weekly recap of everything you can’t miss from the world of startups. Sign up here to get it in your inbox every Friday. Well,…

Startups Weekly: Drama at Techstars. Drama in AI. Drama everywhere.

Last year’s investor dreams of a strong 2024 IPO pipeline have faded, if not fully disappeared, as we approach the halfway point of the year. 2024 delivered four venture-backed tech…

From Plaid to Figma, here are the startups that are likely — or definitely — not having IPOs this year

Federal safety regulators have discovered nine more incidents that raise questions about the safety of Waymo’s self-driving vehicles operating in Phoenix and San Francisco.  The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration…

Feds add nine more incidents to Waymo robotaxi investigation

Terra One’s pitch deck has a few wins, but also a few misses. Here’s how to fix that.

Pitch Deck Teardown: Terra One’s $7.5M Seed deck

Chinasa T. Okolo researches AI policy and governance in the Global South.

Women in AI: Chinasa T. Okolo researches AI’s impact on the Global South

TechCrunch Disrupt takes place on October 28–30 in San Francisco. While the event is a few months away, the deadline to secure your early-bird tickets and save up to $800…

Disrupt 2024 early-bird tickets fly away next Friday