Venture

How to spot investment-worthy founders: Look for mindset, competence and confidence

Comment

A cutout of a side profile of a face with yellow daffodils placed inside, set against a gray background. Illustration of growth mindset. How to spot investment-worthy founders: Look for mindset, competence, and confidence.
Image Credits: Carol Yepes (opens in a new window) / Getty Images

Sanjay Reddy

Contributor

Sanjay Reddy is a co-founding partner of Unlock Venture Partners, a firm focused on early-stage technology investments in Los Angeles and Seattle.

More than 102,000 workers in U.S.-based tech companies have already been laid off in mass job cuts in 2023, according to Crunchbase. Yet for early-stage startups, the outlook isn’t as bleak as the headlines make it out to be — conversely, there’s a huge opportunity for scrappy founders in a downturn. A down market can provide investors with better entry pricing, more time for proper diligence and bigger returns in the long run; early-stage venture capital should be more than prepared to bet on great entrepreneurs in 2023.

Early-stage venture funding is unique. Unlike a Series B or C round, there isn’t a ton of data and metrics to review. Because of this, investors need to rely on the founders to convince them there is a market for their product and that they are the founders to make it happen. As we enter a market downturn, finding and cultivating investment-worthy founders is more important than ever. Whether to invest lies at the intersection of the founder or management team’s mindset, ability and motivation.

Seek out founders with a true entrepreneurial mindset

Early-stage investors need to pick entrepreneurs with a growth mindset. It’s as simple as that. Entrepreneurs that have a strong desire to learn, embrace challenges and aren’t easily knocked down, persist in the face of setbacks, learn from criticism, surround themselves with those that are experts in their field (and trust them), and find lessons and inspiration from other’s successes.

As a fund, we want outsize returns. To deliver those outsize returns, we need to go after a significant total addressable market and challenge to be solved. For an investment that supports a venture outcome, we need to invest in a founder who can stay the course through inevitable challenges. You also need to be sure that the founder you’re investing in wants the same things and won’t bail out on the first exit offer.

In early-stage companies, the focus or thesis can transform as often market conditions and demand for the solution do. That’s why, though opportunity sizing is important, it’s not the determining factor. Early-stage investors must rely on the entrepreneur’s mindset to deliver the outcome; numbers on a spreadsheet can’t do that.

While a founder’s education and work experience come into play, it’s an entrepreneurial mindset that is essential. Willingness to take a risk or walk an untraditional path and ultimately learn from it are critical attributes. So is persistence and grit. Many founders we work with have past startup and founder experience, including some failures. A good entrepreneur is an outlier; they see things others don’t and are willing to go to the wall to back those beliefs.

Questions we ask when sussing out a founder’s mindset include:

  • How have you previously led your team through a crisis?
  • Take us through a smooth/rough day at your company. What went well/wrong and why?
  • How do you motivate your team to get to that next big milestone?
  • Who is a mentor of yours? What and how did you learn from them?
  • Tell me about a disagreement you’ve had with your executive team. How did you come to a compromise?
  • How did you handle layoffs at your past company?
  • When challenged in the past, how did you respond?

Assess founder ability on multiple fronts

Ability encompasses multiple factors, including domain expertise, network, recruiting talent, flexibility, imagination and the ability to raise upstream financing. When identifying entrepreneurs, we evaluate multiple factors through both the questions asked and the quantitative and qualitative information gathered.

Typical questions include:

  • Do you have startup experience? For example, have you worked at, helped scale or founded a startup before?
  • Do you have experience raising institutional funding?
  • How large is/was your team?
  • What were the outcomes of the startup(s) you worked at? Were you acquired? IPO? How did you exit?
  • Have you worked in this sector before?
  • Do you have a network that can accelerate your commercial traction?
  • Do you have control over your finances, both personal and business?
  • How do you communicate your message to investors, coworkers, potential partners, etc.?
  • Have you touched all aspects of a business before? Do you have a general knowledge of how an organization runs smoothly?

Gauge motivation and confidence

So, what can make or break a VC’s decision to move forward with a company? Motivation! Determining motivation is not pure art — there are several factors to consider such as autonomy, relatedness and competence.

An investment-worthy entrepreneur must genuinely believe in their company and be determined to deliver a big outcome. Successful founders don’t find building a company to be work; their company is part of their soul. For an entrepreneur, their company isn’t just business, it’s personal.

Whether to invest in a company ultimately comes down to overall confidence (or lack thereof) in the founders. This confidence is typically based on pattern recognition from the thousands of entrepreneurs we have evaluated over our collective careers. It’s related to the way they talk about their business, their co-founders and employees, how they talk about the future and more.

Some of the questions we ask include:

  • Why are you doing this? Passion? Mission? Chip on the shoulder? Belief?
  • Have you experienced the problem you are trying to solve either in your personal life or business life?
  • Are you committed to delivering an outsized return or will you take the first offer?
  • Do you have a concrete business plan?

Now is an excellent time for venture capitalists to identify and nurture great entrepreneurs with great ideas. Great business ideas can still thrive even when the economy is not doing well. Just look at the many high-profile startups that launched during economic downturns and recessions and have become successful businesses and are still thriving to this day. With the right guidance and support these entrepreneurs can turn their ideas into flourishing businesses and investors can expect great returns.

More TechCrunch

Apple released new data about anti-fraud measures related to its operation of the iOS App Store on Tuesday morning, trumpeting a claim that it stopped over $7 billion in “potentially…

Apple touts stopping $1.8BN in App Store fraud last year in latest pitch to developers

Online travel agency Expedia is testing an AI assistant that bolsters features like search, itinerary building, trip planning, and real-time travel updates.

Expedia starts testing AI-powered features for search and travel planning

Welcome to TechCrunch Fintech! This week, we look at the drama around TabaPay deciding to not buy Synapse’s assets, as well as stocks dropping for a couple of fintechs, Monzo raising…

Inside TabaPay’s drama-filled decision to abandon its plans to buy Synapse’s assets

The person who claimed to have stolen the physical addresses of 49 million Dell customers appears to have taken more data from a different Dell portal, TechCrunch has learned. The…

Threat actor scraped Dell support tickets, including customer phone numbers

If you write the words “cis” or “cisgender” on X, you might be served this full-screen message: “This post contains language that may be considered a slur by X and…

On Elon’s whim, X now treats ‘cisgender’ as a slur

Facebook once had big ambitions to be a major player in enterprise communication and productivity, but today the social network’s parent company Meta will be closing a very significant chapter…

Meta is shutting down Workplace, its enterprise communications business

The Oversight Board has overturned Meta’s decision to take down a documentary revealing the identities of child abuse victims in Pakistan.

Meta’s Oversight Board overturns takedown decision for Pakistan child abuse documentary

The keynote kicks off at 10 a.m. PT on Tuesday and will offer glimpses into the latest versions of Android, Wear OS and Android TV.

Google I/O 2024: How to watch

Adam Selipsky is stepping down from his role as CEO of Amazon Web Services, Amazon has confirmed to TechCrunch.  In a memo shared internally by Amazon CEO Andy Jassy and…

AWS CEO Adam Selipsky steps down

VC and podcaster David Sacks has revealed a new AI chat app called Glue that fixes “Slack channel fatigue,” he says.

David Sacks reveals Glue, the AI company he’s been teasing on his All In podcast

Harness isn’t founder Jyoti Bansal’s first startup. He sold AppDynamics to Cisco for $3.7 billion in 2017, the week it was supposed to go public. His latest venture has raised…

After surpassing $100M in ARR, Harness grabs a $150M line of credit

You can expect plenty of AI, but probably not a lot of hardware.

Google I/O 2024: What to expect

The company’s autonomous vehicles have had a number of misadventures lately, involving driving into construction sites.

Waymo’s robotaxis under investigation after crashes and traffic mishaps

The company is describing the event as “a chance to demo some ChatGPT and GPT-4 updates.”

OpenAI’s ChatGPT announcement: Watch the GPT-4o reveal and demo here

Sona, a workforce management platform for frontline employees, has raised $27.5 million in a Series A round of funding. More than two-thirds of the U.S. workforce are reportedly in frontline…

Sona, a frontline workforce management platform, raises $27.5M with eyes on US expansion

Uber Technologies announced Tuesday that it will buy the Taiwan unit of Delivery Hero’s Foodpanda for $950 million in cash. The deal is part of Uber Eats’ strategy to expand…

Uber to acquire Foodpanda’s Taiwan unit from Delivery Hero for $950M in cash 

Paris-based Blisce has become the latest VC firm to launch a fund dedicated to climate tech. It plans to raise as much as €150M (about $162M).

Paris-based VC firm Blisce launches climate tech fund with a target of $160M

Maad, a B2B e-commerce startup based in Senegal, has secured $3.2 million debt-equity funding to bolster its growth in the western Africa country and to explore fresh opportunities in the…

Maad raises $3.2M seed amid B2B e-commerce sector turbulence in Africa

The fresh funds were raised from two investors who transferred the capital into a special purpose vehicle, a legal entity associated with the OpenAI Startup Fund.

OpenAI Startup Fund raises additional $5M

Accel has invested in more than 200 startups in the region to date, making it one of the more prolific VCs in this market.

Accel has a fresh $650M to back European early-stage startups

Kyle Vogt, the former founder and CEO of self-driving car company Cruise, has a new VC-backed robotics startup focused on household chores. Vogt announced Monday that the new startup, called…

Cruise founder Kyle Vogt is back with a robot startup

When Keith Rabois announced he was leaving Founders Fund to return to Khosla Ventures in January, it came as a shock to many in the venture capital ecosystem — and…

From Miles Grimshaw to Eva Ho, venture capitalists continue to play musical chairs

On the heels of OpenAI announcing the latest iteration of its GPT large language model, its biggest rival in generative AI in the U.S. announced an expansion of its own.…

Anthropic is expanding to Europe and raising more money

If you’re looking for a Starliner mission recap, you’ll have to wait a little longer, because the mission has officially been delayed.

TechCrunch Space: You rock(et) my world, moms

Apple devoted a full event to iPad last Tuesday, roughly a month out from WWDC. From the invite artwork to the polarizing ad spot, Apple was clear — the event…

Apple iPad Pro M4 vs. iPad Air M2: Reviewing which is right for most

Terri Burns, a former partner at GV, is venturing into a new chapter of her career by launching her own venture firm called Type Capital. 

GV’s youngest partner has launched her own firm

The decision to go monochrome was probably a smart one, considering the candy-colored alternatives that seem to want to dazzle and comfort you.

ChatGPT’s new face is a black hole

Apple and Google announced on Monday that iPhone and Android users will start seeing alerts when it’s possible that an unknown Bluetooth device is being used to track them. The…

Apple and Google agree on standard to alert people when unknown Bluetooth devices may be tracking them

A human safety operator will be behind the wheel during this phase of testing, according to the company.

GM’s Cruise ramps up robotaxi testing in Phoenix

OpenAI announced a new flagship generative AI model on Monday that they call GPT-4o — the “o” stands for “omni,” referring to the model’s ability to handle text, speech, and…

OpenAI debuts GPT-4o ‘omni’ model now powering ChatGPT