Featured Article

Best practices for Zoom board meetings at early-stage startups

There are only 4 things a board really needs to consider

Comment

Video call from home during lockdown
Image Credits: Alistair Berg (opens in a new window) / Getty Images

Issac Roth

Contributor
Issac Roth is a Managing Director at Shasta Ventures, and a seasoned entrepreneur who advises founders on open-source technology and keeping communities engaged. Over this career, he’s created and sold multiple enterprise software companies and stays active as an advisor and investor.

More posts from Issac Roth

The world has spent most of 2020 adapting to ever-changing guidelines and restrictions (with no end in sight, even as the vaccines start to roll out). Board meetings are quickly increasing in their significance to foster consistent and vital interactions as an organization. It’s essential for companies to capitalize on the essential time together during these uncertain times.

While we might look like the Brady Bunch while sharing a Zoom window, are you actually communicating more like the family from “Succession?”

Are your meetings organized? Do people talk over one another? Do you usually run over time? Are you giving people time to digest information?

As we move into 2021 and Q1 meetings are being put onto calendars, take some time to modernize how you conduct your board meetings.

Having served on public company boards, growth-stage businesses and Series A startups, an observation I have made in boards that are later stage are more about financial analysis and governance. Whereas earlier-stage board discussions hinge more on product strategy, key partnerships, sharing best practices to help develop founders as executives and important hiring decisions.

Since the nature of the discussions is more, let’s call it … creative in earlier-stage businesses, where the focus is on where they’ve been particularly impacted by reduced bandwidth for collaboration while meeting remotely.

As said best by Mike Maples and paraphrased by Jeff Bonforte — there are only four things a board really needs to consider:

  • Has the market changed since we last met? If so, did it affect us negatively or positively?
  • Has the team changed? For better or worse?
  • Has our position in the market changed?
  • Can we do what we said we would?

Collecting data around those points is the job. In the meeting, the team can add color.

Remember the board works for you, so be sure to put them to work. Sharing materials with participants about three days ahead of time tends to be the best. Any later and they may not get enough time to digest, send earlier and the information might be out of date by the time you meet. It’s most common to format as a deck, but lately I’m seeing more written format and even magazine-style.

The number one request I get from early-stage companies is “help find me more customers.”

Other common requests are “help me find or land this type of talent, help me with industry benchmarks for this type of business deal or compensation structure, connect me to people that have experience with X so I can learn ways we could structure our process.” It’s helpful to put these asks in the materials you send ahead because sometimes board members might not be able to react quickly and now “homework” comes up spontaneously in the discussions.

Another purpose of these meetings is to build working relationships so when strategic decisions need to be made, board members are used to working together. Sometimes it is a forum for executives to gain exposure to board members and for board members to have the opportunity to evaluate and provide input on executives. For that reason execs are often invited to participate in certain discussions.

Like the product person who presents a roadmap or a market analysis, the head of sales should give color on pipeline and competitive deals, the marketing person may lead a discussion on ABM or channel marketing tactics, the engineering lead might ask for feedback on their metrics versus other companies, etc. Generally, CEOs also bring forth an interesting topic to have a discussion, such as channel strategy, market mapping/sizing, hiring plan and related issues.

Logistics

As far as logistics, we reserve two hours in calendars but we try to hit 90 minutes. I suggest something like this for a 90-minute session:

  • 30 mins: Review/discussion of the “four questions” above, color from leadership.
  • 30 mins: Discussion of some topic.
  • 15 mins: Any administrative stuff — options or hiring approvals if these haven’t been done over email.
  • 15 mins: Time for company leadership to step out, let the others talk among themselves and then potentially be called back to receive any feedback.

Prepare an agenda that respects everyone’s time

Being thoughtful about the agenda ahead of time makes a big difference. The big theme is that it’s more difficult to adjust the agenda in real time. In a person-to-person meeting people can interrupt more easily and it’s easier to read the room — are we spending too much time on this, are people engaged and we should stay on this topic for longer, etc.

Because of this more effort needs to be spent up front understanding what everyone wants from the board meeting and crafting the agenda toward that. Solicit input on the agenda ahead of time.

Make introductions

Previously people would introduce themselves while milling around, make sure to introduce new faces (ask them to speak up so “speaker view” highlights them and people can see the face attached to the name, especially in larger groups).

Pause for questions

Pause after an agenda to ask for questions. It’s harder to speak up virtually. (Give a three-second count in your head).

Give attendees time to pre-read

Like Amazon, give people five minutes to do the pre-read (slides or narrative). If they’ve read ahead they can use this moment to fetch a drink or other things they want to do to establish their headspace.

Schedule back-to-back meetings

Set up multiple sessions for different groups in different Zoom URLs at different times. For example, for the executive session or closed session, create a separate link — that way it’s not awkward waiting for people to leave; the right folks can just switch to the other Zoom.

Build in breaks

Don’t ask people if they need a break: Build them into the meeting to give participants time to reset.

No more than nine attendees

The old adage is true, only three people can actually have a discussion; everyone else is just watching. The absolute maximum size for a productive discussion is nine.

Utilize and create the idea of a “second circle,” — have the folks with a board seat put their video on.

Limit the number of presenters

Only one or two execs should present per meeting, and limit time to 15-30 minutes. Board members and observers have to respect the agenda and not drag the meeting into “I want to have an update on X” — or we limit this to a very short session. Everybody tries to give you a formula for how to run your board meeting, but it largely depends on which of your board members can contribute at different stages and different moments.

After the call concludes

Since these meetings make for a good checkpoint of communication of where the company is at, when I was a CEO I would present the same deck (perhaps edited slightly) to the whole company a day or two after the meeting. I would explain what feedback the board had (good and bad, including comments about me so people could help me improve) and what the discussion points had been. If execs were presenting during that section it was a good chance for them to present in front of the company too.

I mean, I’d already done all the work to create the summary, why not use that to update everyone?

Customer advisory boards are a gold mine for startup brand champions

More TechCrunch

The hotel guest management technology company’s platform digitizes the hotel guest journey from post-booking through checkout.

Insight Partners backs Canary Technologies’ mission to elevate hotel guest experiences

The TechCrunch team runs down all of the biggest news from the Apple WWDC 2024 keynote in an easy-to-skim digest.

Here’s everything Apple announced at the WWDC 2024 keynote, including Apple Intelligence, Siri makeover

InScope leverages machine learning and large language models to provide financial reporting and auditing processes for mid-market and enterprises.

VC Sheel Mohnot leads $4.3M seed in automated financial reporting fintech InScope

Venture fundraising has been a slog over the last few years, even for firms with a strong track record. That’s Foresite Capital’s experience. Despite having 47 IPOs, 28 M&As and…

Foresite Capital raises $900M sixth fund for investing in healthcare and life sciences companies

A year ago, Databricks acquired MosaicML for $1.3 billion. Now rebranded as Mosaic AI, the platform has become integral to Databricks’ AI solutions. Today, at the company’s Data + AI…

Databricks expands Mosaic AI to help enterprises build with LLMs

RetailReady targets the $40 billion compliance market to help reduce the number of retail compliance losses that shippers incur annually due to incorrectly shipped packages.

YC grad, RetailReady raises $3.3M for an AI warehouse app that hopes to save brands billions

Since its launch in 2013, Databricks has relied on its ecosystem of partners, such as Fievtran, Rudderstack, and dbt, to provide tools for data preparation and loading. But now, at…

Databricks launches LakeFlow to help its customers build their data pipelines

A big shoutout to the early-stage founders who missed the application window for the Startup Battlefield 200 (SB 200) at TechCrunch Disrupt. We have exciting news just for you! You…

Bonus: An extra week to apply to Startup Battlefield 200

When one of the co-creators of the popular open-source stream-processing framework Apache Flink launches a new startup, it’s worth paying attention. Stephan Ewen was among the founding team of the…

Restate raises $7M for its lightweight workflows-as-code platform

With most residential solar panels installed by smaller companies, customer experience can be a mixed bag. To try to address the quality and consistency problem, Civic Renewables is buying small…

Civic Renewables is rolling up residential solar installers to improve quality and grow the market

Small VC firms require deep trust, mutual support, and long-term commitment among the partners —a kinship that, in many ways, resembles a family dynamic. Colin Anderson (Palantir’s ex-CFO and former…

Friends & Family Capital, a fund founded by ex-Palantir CFO and son of IVP’s founder, unveils third $118M fund

Fisker is issuing the first recall for its all-electric Ocean SUV because of problems with the warning lights, according to new information published by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.…

Fisker’s troubled Ocean SUV gets its first recall

Gorilla, a Belgian company that serves the energy sector with real-time data and analytics for pricing and forecasting, has raised €23 million ($25 million) in a Series B round led…

Gorilla, a Belgian startup that helps energy providers crunch big data, raises $25M

South Korea’s fabless AI chip industry saw a slew of fundraising events over the last couple of years as demand for hardware to power AI applications skyrocketed, and it seems…

Fabless AI chip makers Rebellions and Sapeon to merge as competition heats up in global AI hardware industry

Here’s a list of third-party apps that were Sherlocked by Apple at this year’s WWDC.

The apps that Apple Sherlocked at WWDC 2024

Black Semiconductor, which is developing a chip-connecting technology based on graphene, has raised $273M in a combination of private and public funding. 

Black Semiconductor nabs $273M in Germany to supercharge how chips work together

Featured Article

Let there be Light! Danish startup exits stealth with $13M seed funding to bring AI to general ledgers

It’s not the sexiest of subject matters, but someone needs to talk about it: The CFO tech stack — software used by the chief financial officers of the world — is ripe for disruption. That’s according to Jonathan Sanders, CEO and co-founder of fledgling Danish startup Light, which exits stealth…

7 hours ago
Let there be Light! Danish startup exits stealth with $13M seed funding to bring AI to general ledgers

Fresh off the success of its first mission, satellite manufacturer Apex has closed $95 million in new capital to scale its operations.  The Los Angeles-based startup successfully launched and commissioned…

Apex’s off-the-shelf satellite bus business attracts $95M in new funding

After educating the D.C. market, YC aims to leverage its influence, particularly in areas like competition policy.

DC’s political class doesn’t know Y Combinator exists — yet

Lina Khan says the FTC wants to be effective in its enforcement strategy, which is why it has been taking on lawsuits that “go up against some of the big…

FTC Chair Lina Khan tells TechCrunch the agency is pursuing the ‘mob bosses’ in Big Tech

With dozens of antitrust cases and close to a hundred on the consumer protection side, the agency is now turning to innovative tactics to help it fight fraud, particularly in…

FTC Chair Lina Khan shares how the agency is looking at AI

The ability to pause your activity rings is a minor feature update for most, but for those of us who obsess about such things to an unhealthy degree, it’s the…

Apple Watch is finally adding a feature I’ve been requesting for years

Featured Article

Why Apple is taking a small-model approach to generative AI

It’s a very Apple approach in the sense that it prioritizes a frictionless user experience above all.

15 hours ago
Why Apple is taking a small-model approach to generative AI

When generative AI tools started making waves in late 2022 after the launch of ChatGPT, the finance industry was one of the first to recognize these tools’ potential for speeding…

Linq raises $6.6M to use AI to make research easier for financial analysts

In addition to the federal funding, the state of New Mexico — where SolAero is based — committed to providing financing and incentives that value $25.5 million.

Biden administration looks to give Rocket Lab $24M to boost space-grade solar cell production

Some of the new Apple Intelligence features that Apple debuted at WWDC 2024 don’t even feel like AI, they just feel like smarter tools. 

Apple’s AI, Apple Intelligence, is boring and practical — that’s why it works

Jordan Meyer and Mathew Dryhurst founded Spawning AI to create tools that help artists exert more control over how their works are used online. Their latest project, called Source.Plus, is…

Spawning wants to build more ethical AI training datasets

After leading the social media landscape, TikTok appears to be interested in challenging Google’s dominance in search. The company confirmed to TechCrunch that it’s testing the ability for users to…

TikTok comes for Google as it quietly rolls out image search capabilities in TikTok Shop

General Motors is investing $850 million into Cruise as the autonomous vehicle subsidiary slowly makes its way back to testing in Phoenix, Dallas and, as of Tuesday, Houston. GM’s CFO…

GM gives Cruise $850M lifeline as it relaunches robotaxis in Houston

These messaging features, announced at WWDC 2024, will have a significant impact on how people communicate every day.

At last, Apple’s Messages app will support RCS and scheduling texts