Featured Article

Mayfield’s Arvind Gupta discusses startup fundraising during a downturn

‘You can still finance hopes and dreams, but just with smaller dollars’

Comment

a rubber duck sits in a lonely puddle
Image Credits: diephosi (opens in a new window) / Getty Images (Image has been modified)

Between his roles as co-leader of Mayfield Fund’s engineering biology practice and founder at IndieBio, Arvind Gupta reviewed approximately 470 startup pitches last year.

He characterizes his process as “simple,” but that is a bit reductive: after reviewing a deck and scheduling a meeting with the founders, he’ll spend many hours acquainting himself with both the underlying technology and the individuals on the team.

“For seed deals, I spend a maximum of 10 days so I can give an answer to a founder and I make it a pledge,” he said last week during a TechCrunch+ Twitter Space. “In 10 days, I can do the primary research and work with the founders to come to a conclusion there. For a larger Series A check. It could take a little bit longer than that, but not that much.”

I interviewed Gupta last month to find out more about the opportunities he’s looking for and get his advice for first-time founders, but last week’s Space was a chance to dive deeper. When I suggested that the downturn in the public markets might give startups a chance to focus on finding product-market fit instead of chasing growth, he gave me a personal market correction:

Recessions or downturns are always the hardest times to build businesses, always, for the entrepreneurs, for VCs, for everyone involved. Because no one cares if the market is terrible. It’s not like you get a buy: “forget it, we’ll just never mind that returns are terrible.”

Our conversation unearthed a lot of useful advice about fundraising in a down market, why he believes now is still a good time to start up, and how founders can avoid waving one big, red flag that discourages many investors:

“Just like [some] VCs are arrogant, I think it’s important to have a learning mindset for entrepreneurs.” Gupta said. “Entrepreneurs that believe they know everything had better be right, because it’s gonna be hard to learn on the fly if you already know everything.”

This transcript has been edited for space and clarity.

TechCrunch: The downturn in the public markets is impacting early-stage valuations, but seed-stage funding still seems pretty stable. Is this still a good time to start up?

Arvind Gupta: I think it is, especially in what I do, which is reversing climate change and curing disease. It’s always a good time to start up, because those things can’t wait.

What’s happened with the stock market is, as valuations have come down, multiples have compressed… So let’s say revenues are $100 million and if the IPO value of a company is $2 billion, that’s 10x sales. That has gone down considerably, about 30% from where it used to be. The private markets don’t get repriced every single day, so it takes some time for that to catch up.

Late-stage investing has definitely dried up quite a bit… It’s just a matter of time before it sort of trickles down, but there’s a lot of cash in the system right now. Most large VCs raise huge seed funds, there’s microfunds everywhere, and angels are extremely active. There’s a lot of optimism that technology can still create real solutions that can drive real value creation. So I haven’t seen a slowdown at all really, in the seed, pre-seed or Series A areas.

Seed-stage actually persists even during economic downturns because people still seem willing to make small bets. What’s your sense as far as why that is?

When you’re investing huge buckets of money, generally you’re not investing in a story and a hope and a dream, you’re investing in a business that’s showing traction. Now, there’s some extremely capital-intensive businesses where you need buckets of money before that traction is generated, and that becomes harder to finance in downturns.

You can still finance hopes and dreams, but just with smaller dollars, and you’re generally going to give up a little bit more of your company in terms of dilution during an economic downturn, so I expect that to start happening as well in the next year.

Who’s going to have a harder time in this new environment?

I’ve always said that the low-interest rate environment that we’ve had really since 2008 has generated an interest-free loan on risky startups.

So when you start looking at, “oh, it’s gonna be $150 million before we generate our first dollar of revenue,” that’s going to generate a deep breath in the meeting. After that $150 million is in, tell me about that next stage — that’s going to require more creative business models, different go-to-market strategies that generate revenues along the way. For good entrepreneurs, there’s always a path, right? It’s just different in different economic environments, it’s never shut, so to speak.


Full TechCrunch+ articles are only available to members
Use discount code TWITTERSPACES to save 20% off a one- or two-year subscription


You asked me for some categories? I think climate investing, what I do, is still extremely brisk. And there seems to be very little hesitation by investors to wonder about business models or downstream capex, I think for for other sectors, you know, with SaaS and things like that, those are traditional businesses, where you have the revenues, you have the metrics, there are multiples, it’s almost like an equation that people plug in: “Okay, this is what this company is worth.”

I think it depends on where the world goes in the next year: If the world stays kind of like this and goes laterally, everything will be fine. And there’ll be plenty of money to go around.

What sort of market conditions should we look for that would precede a rebound in late-stage startup funding?

What will happen is, as the IPO market opens back up, a lot of these IPOs that are underwater right now start to go back to the original IPO price and LPs that are writing down their portfolio start to see their portfolio come back up, that allocation for venture capital continues to grow, and then venture capital continues to deploy and redeploy the money that comes in.

The exit value is what drives it all. So seeing the technology sector and the NASDAQ start to rebound near its old highs, or even within 20% of its old highs, that’ll be the precipitating factor of the market staying open and money flowing.

From a founder perspective, it seems easier to hire during a correction, and it might be a little easier to retain employees. I’m getting the impression that founders are under less pressure to worship the god of growth, do I have that right? Or are investors still putting them under the microscope?

No, I think you’re always going to be under the microscope, growth is still important. Recessions or downturns are always the hardest times to build businesses, always, for the entrepreneurs, for VCs, for everyone involved. Because no one cares if the market is terrible. It’s not like you get a buy: “forget it, we’ll just never mind that returns are terrible.”

It all rolls kind of downhill from where the money is originating from, which is actually pension funds, retirement funds, and things like that, important endowments, and so that’s all of our money in general. It’s always a hard time, and anyone that thinks otherwise is deluded. And so growth is really important. Finding that product-market fit is really important, and doing that efficiently with the least amount of dollars is critical.

How much time do you spend reviewing each pitch?

Reviewing a pitch means sitting with the founders, hearing the pitch, asking questions and interacting with them. Generally, the process is pretty simple. You review a pitch deck, and if it’s in the strike zone of what you’re looking at, [investors] say, ‘yeah, this is something that I want to learn more about.”

And then you generally have a half an hour or an hour introductory call, or Zoom for the past two years, and now opening back up to in an office, or at their offices. And that’s a really great way to just get to know the founders and understand the technology and spend your time.

For seed deals, I spend a maximum of 10 days so I can give an answer to a founder and I make it a pledge. I’ve seen a lot of VCs waste a lot of founders’ time, because they’re just curious about stuff. In 10 days, I can do the primary research and work with founders to come to a conclusion there. For a larger Series A check. It could take a little bit longer than that, but not that much.

I think speed is really important. There’s a phrase I use, which is, “time kills all deals.” And so you want to push towards a resolution on a deal, whether you’re an investor or a founder, or an entrepreneur.

Approximately how many pitches did you look at yesterday?

Let’s say three founders today, and I reviewed probably two or three decks yesterday.

Do you have a sense of how many you looked at in 2021?

Yeah, 470, upper four hundreds. I keep track of every single company I’ve ever met. And I have a spreadsheet.

What’s getting better? And what’s getting worse, as far as the pitches you’re looking at?

I’m starting to see entrepreneurs figure out that you can stratify markets by looking at certain customers that have a high propensity to pay, but a smaller market. So they’ll say, “OK, I’ll address that one first, and then as we raise more money and scale, we’ll go to bigger markets where they will bear the lower cost of product.” Five or seven years ago, I had to explain that all the time to literally every single entrepreneur I invested in.

But the timeless arts of storytelling? That stuff can always be improved. The thing that I would love to see more of is: how does the world change if you’re successful? That’s something that I don’t hear often. Either the founder hasn’t thought about it, or the founder assumes everyone knows what they know about how the world will change.

The investor might think the world will change in one way and the founder is thinking another way. We call that the cake/souffle problem, because the same ingredients are required to bake a cake as to make a souffle, but they’re very different things.

A first-time founder has to figure out how much of a market they’re going to go after and how much it’s worth. How good are first-time founders at estimating TAM, SAM and SOM, and how important is it to you as an investor?

Founders often overestimate the TAM, this is the most common TAM issue. Founders will say, “our TAM is $30 billion,” and you’ll be like, “yeah, but you’re not doing all of healthcare, you’re doing this one slice of it.”

Being precise is a good proxy for thinking about the precision of the company and its founders. That’s probably a big part of the pitching process that I’m looking for, because it tells me about how they’re going to think in the future. My whole point in being an investor is to be a partner in helping founders do really difficult things. And so when you see someone that is precise, then you know that as things become extremely complex — which they always do — they’ll be in the habit of actually being precise.

Are you open to founders who don’t have direct experience doing the thing they want to build? “I have a great idea, I’ve done some research, I’m not a biotechnologist, but I’ve got an idea for a cell-cultured meat product I think is gonna do really well.”

What would it take to convince you that I had the goods to actually pull this off?

I’m an underdog and I’ve funded underdogs. Any buyer’s premise is to find people that are not-traditional scientists become entrepreneurs. I think there’s no problem with that. But you need expertise on the team. So this is the team approach, right? So if I have no experience, and I come to you [and say] “Hey, I’ve got a cure for cancer. You know, in my kitchen, just give me five million bucks, and I can scale it up?”

Whatever, dude.

That’s like getting pitched by Dr. Evil from “Austin Powers.”

Yeah, it’s just silly.

But if I say, “well, I have no experience in the space, but I have a lot of drive, a lot of energy and I’ve used it to bring some of the world’s best people in that space together. And we all believe that this is possible. And we all are willing to give up our day jobs and or give up our jobs and actually make this our real job to make this happen?” That’s exciting.

What are some of the most common red flags you see when you’re being pitched?

It’s important as an investor to be extremely humble, because we’re going to be wrong a lot. I have this phrase that I use all the time: knowledge competes with imagination.

Imagination is what is required to really understand and think about how, how can the world change? Can people eat meat that was grown in a lab? That’s imagination. And then there’s knowledge. Knowledge is like, “no.” So they compete all the time, which is why really deep experts in an area tend to think nothing works.

Great investors and great entrepreneurs often come orthogonally into a space because they aren’t encumbered by that deep, ingrained, often wrong knowledge. And one of my favorite books is Thomas Kuhns, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, which talks about this in depth. That’s the premise before I dive into all this stuff, because these can be red flags for me and I could be wrong.

I think precision will show depth of thinking, depth of knowledge, and clarity. Clarity is also important. When I’m teaching all these companies to raise and pitch I always say, “clarity creates confidence.”

If you can clearly articulate what it is you’re doing and why it matters to the world and then clearly and with clarity explain the underlying technology and the moat, you’re gonna create a lot of confidence in the people around you, your employees, the people that want to write about you, your investors. Clarity creates confidence all around you. And that becomes a halo. And it’s a huge value.

Just like [some] VCs are arrogant, I think it’s important to have a learning mindset for entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs that believe they know everything had better be right, because it’s gonna be hard to learn on the fly if you already know everything. Being open to learning and being open to having help is another quality that’s critically important, especially in deep science. A founder that isn’t open and humble about the complexity that actually exists in the world is one that’s tough to back, at least for me. It’s a style thing.

How important is confidence? Will you back someone who seems less than fully confident in their ability to pull off their idea?

There’s confidence, there’s bravado, and then there’s arrogance. I don’t really like the latter two. The CEO of the last company I funded at Mayfield is quiet, but she has an incredible sense of confidence about her, because of everything she’s done in her life and what she’s gone through. That’s awesome stuff.

It starts with the founder, because they’re the one driving it. But if the founder is overly confident or overlooks natural complexities and doesn’t regard them with respect, then I have a hard time funding that person, because a lot of things deserve respect in the world.

One of the most important things I look for are mission-driven people, because mission-driven people are going to naturally want help, they’re going to naturally look at the world as complex, because they’re actually there, they’re trying to solve a problem for something other than monetary gain, or seeing their name in TechCrunch or in The New York Times.

Do you have any advice at all for someone who’s on the fence about launching a startup? What’s one thing a first-time founder can do to boost their confidence?

I don’t invest in solutions, I invest in problems. That’s really important.

If you find a really amazing problem in the world… and [can explain] why if you can eliminate that problem, the world changes in a fundamental way, that opens the door all day for me. And then if you can follow that up with a plan to actually solve that problem, that creates a moat. Then, you have a barrier to entry for others, and that you have a team in place that can credibly execute against that plan.

That’s everything you need.

How do you prefer to be approached: a cold email or a warm intro?

It doesn’t matter to me. If you cold email someone, and they don’t reply, cold email them again, right? Make someone say, “stop emailing me!” If you’re on a mission, go solve for the mission, and find the right partners. If someone’s trying to reach me… that’s not a problem.

Would it be crazy if I asked you to share your email address right now? Right here?

Arvind@gmail.com? Pretty easy.

What kinds of investment opportunities are you looking for in Q3 2022?

I’m looking for companies that are controlling the distribution of carbon and companies that are able to do price discovery around carbon. I’m looking for platform therapeutics that have functional screens and ways of generating novel targets. I’m also looking for companies that are able to control consumer-facing supply of carbon-negative production methods, so vertically-integrated brands that are making new materials. I’ve been looking for fashion companies that have renewable materials, things like that.

Basically, it comes down to this: I’m looking for companies that are reversing climate change and curing disease. That’s it. If you have a company that does either of those two things. I’m interested in speaking to you.

More TechCrunch

Anterior, a company that uses AI to expedite health insurance approval for medical procedures, has raised a $20 million Series A round at a $95 million post-money valuation led by…

Anterior grabs $20M from NEA to expedite health insurance approvals with AI

Welcome back to TechCrunch’s Week in Review — TechCrunch’s newsletter recapping the week’s biggest news. Want it in your inbox every Saturday? Sign up here. There’s more bad news for…

How India’s most valuable startup ended up being worth nothing

If death and taxes are inevitable, why are companies so prepared for taxes, but not for death? “I lost both of my parents in college, and it didn’t initially spark…

Bereave wants employers to suck a little less at navigating death

Google and Microsoft have made their developer conferences a showcase of their generative AI chops, and now all eyes are on next week’s Worldwide Developers Conference, which is expected to…

Apple needs to focus on making AI useful, not flashy

AI systems and large language models need to be trained on massive amounts of data to be accurate but they shouldn’t train on data that they don’t have the rights…

Deal Dive: Human Native AI is building the marketplace for AI training licensing deals

Before Wazer came along, “water jet cutting” and “affordable” didn’t belong in the same sentence. That changed in 2016, when the company launched the world’s first desktop water jet cutter,…

Wazer Pro is making desktop water jetting more affordable

Former Autonomy chief executive Mike Lynch issued a statement Thursday following his acquittal of criminal charges, ending a 13-year legal battle with Hewlett-Packard that became one of Silicon Valley’s biggest…

Autonomy’s Mike Lynch acquitted after US fraud trial brought by HP

Featured Article

What Snowflake isn’t saying about its customer data breaches

As another Snowflake customer confirms a data breach, the cloud data company says its position “remains unchanged.”

21 hours ago
What Snowflake isn’t saying about its customer data breaches

Investor demand has been so strong for Rippling’s shares that it is letting former employees particpate in its tender offer. With one exception.

Rippling bans former employees who work at competitors like Deel and Workday from its tender offer stock sale

It turns out the space industry has a lot of ideas on how to improve NASA’s $11 billion, 15-year plan to collect and return samples from Mars. Seven of these…

NASA puts $10M down on Mars sample return proposals from Blue Origin, SpaceX and others

Featured Article

In 2024, many Y Combinator startups only want tiny seed rounds — but there’s a catch

When Bowery Capital general partner Loren Straub started talking to a startup from the latest Y Combinator accelerator batch a few months ago, she thought it was strange that the company didn’t have a lead investor for the round it was raising. Even stranger, the founders didn’t seem to be…

1 day ago
In 2024, many Y Combinator startups only want tiny seed rounds — but there’s a catch

The keynote will be focused on Apple’s software offerings and the developers that power them, including the latest versions of iOS, iPadOS, macOS, tvOS, visionOS and watchOS.

Watch Apple kick off WWDC 2024 right here

Welcome to Startups Weekly — Haje’s weekly recap of everything you can’t miss from the world of startups. Anna will be covering for him this week. Sign up here to…

Startups Weekly: Ups, downs, and silver linings

HSBC and BlackRock estimate that the Indian edtech giant Byju’s, once valued at $22 billion, is now worth nothing.

BlackRock has slashed the value of stake in Byju’s, once worth $22 billion, to zero

Apple is set to board the runaway locomotive that is generative AI at next week’s World Wide Developer Conference. Reports thus far have pointed to a partnership with OpenAI that…

Apple’s generative AI offering might not work with the standard iPhone 15

LinkedIn has confirmed it will no longer allow advertisers to target users based on data gleaned from their participation in LinkedIn Groups. The move comes more than three months after…

LinkedIn to limit targeted ads in EU after complaint over sensitive data use

Founders: Need plans this weekend? What better way to spend your time than applying to this year’s Startup Battlefield 200 at TechCrunch Disrupt. With Monday’s deadline looming, this is a…

Startup Battlefield 200 applications due Monday

The company is in the process of building a gigawatt-scale factory in Kentucky to produce its nickel-hydrogen batteries.

Novel battery manufacturer EnerVenue is raising $515M, per filing

Meta is quietly rolling out a new “Communities” feature on Messenger, the company confirmed to TechCrunch. The feature is designed to help organizations, schools and other private groups communicate in…

Meta quietly rolls out Communities on Messenger

Featured Article

Siri and Google Assistant look to generative AI for a new lease on life

Voice assistants in general are having an existential moment, and generative AI is poised to be the logical successor.

1 day ago
Siri and Google Assistant look to generative AI for a new lease on life

Education software provider PowerSchool is being taken private by investment firm Bain Capital in a $5.6 billion deal.

Bain to take K-12 education software provider PowerSchool private in $5.6B deal

Shopify has acquired Threads.com, the Sequoia-backed Slack alternative, Threads said on its website. The companies didn’t disclose the terms of the deal but said that the Threads.com team will join…

Shopify acquires Threads (no, not that one)

Featured Article

Bangladeshi police agents accused of selling citizens’ personal information on Telegram

Two senior police officials in Bangladesh are accused of collecting and selling citizens’ personal information to criminals on Telegram.

2 days ago
Bangladeshi police agents accused of selling citizens’ personal information on Telegram

Carta, a once-high-flying Silicon Valley startup that loudly backed away from one of its businesses earlier this year, is working on a secondary sale that would value the company at…

Carta’s valuation to be cut by $6.5 billion in upcoming secondary sale

Boeing’s Starliner spacecraft has successfully delivered two astronauts to the International Space Station, a key milestone in the aerospace giant’s quest to certify the capsule for regular crewed missions.  Starliner…

Boeing’s Starliner overcomes leaks and engine trouble to dock with ‘the big city in the sky’

Rivian needs to sell its new revamped vehicles at a profit in order to sustain itself long enough to get to the cheaper mass market R2 SUV on the road.

Rivian’s path to survival is now remarkably clear

Featured Article

What to expect from WWDC 2024: iOS 18, macOS 15 and so much AI

Apple is hoping to make WWDC 2024 memorable as it finally spells out its generative AI plans.

2 days ago
What to expect from WWDC 2024: iOS 18, macOS 15 and so much AI

As WWDC 2024 nears, all sorts of rumors and leaks have emerged about what iOS 18 and its AI-powered apps and features have in store.

What to expect from Apple’s AI-powered iOS 18 at WWDC 2024

Apple’s annual list of what it considers the best and most innovative software available on its platform is turning its attention to the little guy.

Apple’s Design Awards highlight indies and startups

Meta launched its Meta Verified program today along with other features, such as the ability to call large businesses and custom messages.

Meta rolls out Meta Verified for WhatsApp Business users in Brazil, India, Indonesia and Colombia