Startups

4 lessons I learned about getting into Y Combinator (after 13 applications)

Comment

Image of a chair and a trash can in an office, with the bin surrounded by crumpled paper, representing persistence.
Image Credits: Peter Finch (opens in a new window) / Getty Images

Alex Circei

Contributor

Alex Circei is the CEO and co-founder of Waydev, a development analytics tool that measures engineering teams’ performance.

More posts from Alex Circei

For many founders, Y Combinator is a coveted milestone on the entrepreneurial road. As of January 2021, the accelerator has helped create 60,000 jobs, has 125 companies valued over $150 million, and has facilitated top exits totaling more than $300 billion. Past alumni include Airbnb, DoorDash and Coinbase — all of which are now publicly traded.

Unsurprisingly, the program has a strict selection process — with rumors claiming that less than 5% of startups are accepted, making Y Combinator one of the most prestigious accelerators out there. Competition may be fierce, but it’s not impossible, and jumping through some hoops is not only worth the potential payoff but is ultimately a valuable learning curve for any startup.

The entrepreneurs trying to get into Y Combinator are often at an early point in their journeys and haven’t yet built up the experience to know exactly what kind of business can hit the ground running. This is where a harsh journey of trial and error helps entrepreneurs face the reality of their business model. Going through the Y Combinator program’s rigorous vetting gives founders a sense-check of what they’re missing, and who they’re missing. Take it from someone who applied to the program 13 times before getting in.

Of course, 13 applications require a degree of time and money that startups don’t always have, so I’ve condensed my four biggest takeaways from the experience. Here’s how to work toward landing in the small percentage of startups successfully accepted to the Y Combinator program:

Put your business value before your personal vanity

In a sea of applications, it’s easy to feel like you have to distinguish yourself and your startup in a striking way. For me, I made my mark through an encounter with Paul Graham, one of the founders of Y Combinator — although not in the way I had hoped for.

Graham had written a lot of online essays and resources for startups. In 2012, I thought it would be great to download Graham’s essays, browse by most-used words and publish my findings on Hacker News. However, Hacker News is the social news website run by Y Combinator, and the morning after I shared my work I woke up to an email from Graham asking me to swiftly take it down.

I then spent weeks worrying that the events would prevent me from ever getting accepted into the program. I had hardly made a good first impression on one of the most influential figures in the organization.

Looking back on things now, though, I realize that that experience with Graham was never held against me at Y Combinator because it didn’t rise to the level of being truly problematic. Y Combinator isn’t bluffing when it says it wants founders to make “something people want.” My application always came back to how much value my business could bring the world.

Bring a co-founder on board to diversify your perspective

I first applied to Y Combinator back in 2010, but it wasn’t until 2016 that I stumbled upon the idea that would carve a whole new path for me. As I was advising a startup, I came across Github graphs as a straightforward way to understand engineer output. The visualized data inspired me to build a type of Google Analytics for software development, which ultimately became the foundation for my current company. And while I was sure I’d found my niche — and, more importantly, something people want — the vision alone wasn’t enough. I needed a technical co-founder to bring it to life.

I made it my priority to find a co-founder who could easily navigate the logistics of my idea. I already knew that a co-founder could increase my chances of success in terms of the product, but it also turned out to be a boost for our subsequent Y Combinator applications. Why? Because it demonstrated a longer path of entrepreneurship — it showed that I could connect with other founders and that I was able to collaborate and harness others’ skill sets.

Being an entrepreneur often comes with a degree of ego — we want to do everything ourselves, to be the only ones responsible for moving things forward. But this mentality is counterproductive and keeps us in our silos, leading us to make the same mistakes over and over. There’s a reason 54% of the most successful startups listed on Crunchbase have two or more founders. They give you another pair of hands to fix things and another set of eyes to broaden your lens.

Finding a co-founder isn’t the end of the story. After I found Valentin Buzea, our amazing technical co-founder, we decided to take Y Combinator’s free online Startup School course. We both wanted to be on the same page when it came to the application, and the course allowed us to be better aligned, as well as informed. I would also recommend Startup School as a way to stay productive while preparing or pending an application answer from Y Combinator.

Engage with other alumni and make them your advisers and ambassadors

The Y Combinator community is fantastic — even if you haven’t been accepted into the program yet, there are plenty of ways to leverage alumni and Y Combinator resources.

Before and in between waiting for responses from Y Combinator about my various applications, I would log on to LinkedIn, search “Y Combinator,” and compile a list of companies who were associated with the program or had taken the program. I would then reach out to them, asking for their stories and advice. This always proved fruitful because people were flattered that I was asking for their opinions, and because they could empathize with my position — they knew how grueling the process could be.

At the same time, I signed up to Stripe Atlas, a platform that helps companies launch in the United States. The membership gave me access to a WhatsApp channel where I could discuss Y Combinator tips with entrepreneurs, investors and thought leaders. I would also share drafts of my applications on the forum and receive detailed feedback from a number of Stripe professionals. What’s more, many of these people vouched for us on Bookface, Y Combinator’s private platform where members recommend startups they think fit the program mold.

The more connections we made between applications, the stronger the next application became.

Demonstrate the right traction with growth metrics

By January 2019, eight Y Combinator applications later, my co-founder and I decided to fully launch. We were confident we had our target market down, a polished product, and we were even able to collect a decent amount of traction — including purchase intent. Surely at this point Y Combinator would welcome us.

Nope. The traction we had didn’t sufficiently prove that our product was something people wanted. Our metrics were too low to be representative or signal longevity. Naturally, it’s hard for startups to earn large volumes of customers from the get-go, but what we should have focused on was growth: user growth, revenue growth, retention growth and so on. We also needed to highlight quality (not quantity) metrics like big-name customers, positive reviews and publication features.

Finally, after 20 months of perfecting metrics, the product and pitching, lucky number 13 came and we were invited to join Y Combinator.

Of course, my Y Combinator journey spans well beyond these four hard-earned lessons. Yet, truthfully, I’m happy I didn’t get accepted earlier, because I now know that those startups wouldn’t have been successful. Hopefully, with these insights, fellow founders can follow suit — albeit in a much shorter time frame!

Our favorite companies from Y Combinator’s W21 Demo Day: Part 1

More TechCrunch

The AI industry moves faster than the rest of the technology sector, which means it outpaces the federal government by several orders of magnitude.

Senate study proposes ‘at least’ $32B yearly for AI programs

The FBI along with a coalition of international law enforcement agencies seized the notorious cybercrime forum BreachForums on Wednesday.  For years, BreachForums has been a popular English-language forum for hackers…

FBI seizes hacking forum BreachForums — again

The announcement signifies a significant shake-up in the streaming giant’s advertising approach.

Netflix to take on Google and Amazon by building its own ad server

It’s tough to say that a $100 billion business finds itself at a critical juncture, but that’s the case with Amazon Web Services, the cloud arm of Amazon, and the…

Matt Garman taking over as CEO with AWS at crossroads

Back in February, Google paused its AI-powered chatbot Gemini’s ability to generate images of people after users complained of historical inaccuracies. Told to depict “a Roman legion,” for example, Gemini would show…

Google still hasn’t fixed Gemini’s biased image generator

A feature Google demoed at its I/O confab yesterday, using its generative AI technology to scan voice calls in real time for conversational patterns associated with financial scams, has sent…

Google’s call-scanning AI could dial up censorship by default, privacy experts warn

Google’s going all in on AI — and it wants you to know it. During the company’s keynote at its I/O developer conference on Tuesday, Google mentioned “AI” more than…

The top AI announcements from Google I/O

Uber is taking a shuttle product it developed for commuters in India and Egypt and converting it for an American audience. The ride-hail and delivery giant announced Wednesday at its…

Uber has a new way to solve the concert traffic problem

Here are quick hits of the biggest news from the keynote as they are announced.

Google I/O 2024: Here’s everything Google just announced

Google is preparing to launch a new system to help address the problem of malware on Android. Its new live threat detection service leverages Google Play Protect’s on-device AI to…

Google takes aim at Android malware with an AI-powered live threat detection service

Users will be able to access the AR content by first searching for a location in Google Maps.

Google Maps is getting geospatial AR content later this year

The heat pump startup unveiled its first products and revealed details about performance, pricing and availability.

Quilt heat pump sports sleek design from veterans of Apple, Tesla and Nest

The space is available from the launcher and can be locked as a second layer of authentication.

Google’s new Private Space feature is like Incognito Mode for Android

Gemini, the company’s family of generative AI models, will enhance the smart TV operating system so it can generate descriptions for movies and TV shows.

Google TV to launch AI-generated movie descriptions

When triggered, the AI-powered feature will automatically lock the device down.

Android’s new Theft Detection Lock helps deter smartphone snatch and grabs

The company said it is increasing the on-device capability of its Google Play Protect system to detect fraudulent apps trying to breach sensitive permissions.

Google adds live threat detection and screen-sharing protection to Android

This latest release, one of many announcements from the Google I/O 2024 developer conference, focuses on improved battery life and other performance improvements, like more efficient workout tracking.

Wear OS 5 hits developer preview, offering better battery life

For years, Sammy Faycurry has been hearing from his registered dietitian (RD) mom and sister about how poorly many Americans eat and their struggles with delivering nutritional counseling. Although nearly…

Dietitian startup Fay has been booming from Ozempic patients and emerges from stealth with $25M from General Catalyst, Forerunner

Apple is bringing new accessibility features to iPads and iPhones, designed to cater to a diverse range of user needs.

Apple announces new accessibility features for iPhone and iPad users

TechCrunch Disrupt, our flagship startup event held annually in San Francisco, is back on October 28-30 — and you can expect a bustling crowd of thousands of startup enthusiasts. Exciting…

Startup Blueprint: TC Disrupt 2024 Builders Stage agenda sneak peek!

Mike Krieger, one of the co-founders of Instagram and, more recently, the co-founder of personalized news app Artifact (which TechCrunch corporate parent Yahoo recently acquired), is joining Anthropic as the…

Anthropic hires Instagram co-founder as head of product

Seven orgs so far have signed on to standardize the way data is collected and shared.

Venture orgs form alliance to standardize data collection

As cloud adoption continues to surge toward the $1 trillion mark in annual spend, we’re seeing a wave of enterprise startups gaining traction with customers and investors for tools to…

Alkira connects with $100M for a solution that connects your clouds

Charging has long been the Achilles’ heel of electric vehicles. One startup thinks it has a better way for apartment dwelling EV drivers to charge overnight.

Orange Charger thinks a $750 outlet will solve EV charging for apartment dwellers

So did investors laugh them out of the room when they explained how they wanted to replace Quickbooks? Kind of.

Embedded accounting startup Layer secures $2.3M toward goal of replacing QuickBooks

While an increasing number of companies are investing in AI, many are struggling to get AI-powered projects into production — much less delivering meaningful ROI. The challenges are many. But…

Weka raises $140M as the AI boom bolsters data platforms

PayHOA, a previously bootstrapped Kentucky-based startup that offers software for self-managed homeowner associations (HOAs), is an example of how real-world problems can translate into opportunity. It just raised a $27.5…

Meet PayHOA, a profitable and once-bootstrapped SaaS startup that just landed a $27.5M Series A

Restaurant365, which offers a restaurant management suite, has raised a hot $175M from ICONIQ Growth, KKR and L Catterton.

Restaurant365 orders in $175M at $1B+ valuation to supersize its food service software stack 

Venture firm Shilling has launched a €50M fund to support growth-stage startups in its own portfolio and to invest in startups everywhere else. 

Portuguese VC firm Shilling launches €50M opportunity fund to back growth-stage startups

Chang She, previously the VP of engineering at Tubi and a Cloudera veteran, has years of experience building data tooling and infrastructure. But when She began working in the AI…

LanceDB, which counts Midjourney as a customer, is building databases for multimodal AI